John 1:3 (World English Bible)“Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made.”
John 1:10 (World English Bible)
“He was in the world, and though the world was made through him, the world did not recognize him.”A common claim is that John 1:3 teaches that absolutely everything in the universe was created through Jesus Christ, the Word. From this, some conclude that Jesus must be the “uncreated Creator,” since “nothing was made without him.”
One author puts it this way:
Some heretical cults deny Christ’s eternal existence, claiming that He was a created Being. In contrast to this false doctrine, the Bible presents Him as the uncreated Creator… “All things were made by him…” (John 1:3). In the beginning He was not created or made. In the beginning He already was (John 1:1–2)! The Apostle Paul declares that “He is before all things” (Col. 1:17).
This reasoning sounds airtight—until we examine what John actually says, how Greek words like panta (“all”) function, and what “the beginning” refers to in Scripture.
1. John 1:3 Does Not Say Jesus Is Uncreated
The text presents Jesus as the instrument God used in the creation being discussed—not as the Creator Himself.
A few key observations:
a. The Bible never calls Jesus “the Creator.”
Not once.
Jesus Himself applies the words creation and Creator to his God and Father (Mark 10:6; 13:19), never to himself.The idea of Jesus as “the uncreated Creator” is imported into the text, not drawn from it.
b. Other spirit “sons of God” were present at the beginning of the world of mankind.
Job 38:4–7 shows the angels rejoicing when God laid earth’s foundations.
Thus, the “beginning” of John 1:1–3 is not the beginning of the universe or the beginning of all creation.
2. What the Greek Text Actually Says
From the Westcott & Hort interlinear:
panta di’ autou egeneto … oude hen ho gegonen ALL (THINGS) THROUGH HIM CAME TO BE … NOT ONE WHICH HAS COME TO BEThe words “things” and “thing” are not in the Greek. They are supplied by translators.
John literally says:
“All through him came to be, and apart from him not one came to be.”
This raises the question: All of what?
The answer must come from context—not from assumptions.
3. The Scope of “All” (panta) Is Context‑Dependent
The Greek word pas (“all”) rarely means “absolutely everything without exception.”
It almost always means “all within the category being discussed.”Example: Romans 8:22
“The whole creation [pasa ktisis] groans…”
This “whole creation” does not include:
- angels
- stars
- galaxies
- the heavenly realm
It refers specifically to the human world subjected to futility (Romans 8:20; 5:12–19).
Likewise, in John 1:3, panta refers to all within the creation being discussed—not the entire universe.
John 1:10 clarifies the category
“He was in the world, and the world was made through him…”
The “world” (kosmos) in John consistently refers to the world of mankind, not the universe.
Thus, the “all” of John 1:3 matches the “world” of John 1:10.
4. “Not One” (oude hen) Also Depends on Context
Hebrews 2:8 says:
“He left nothing that is not subject to him.”
Does this mean God subjected the entire universe to mankind?
Of course not.Psalm 8:6–8 defines the scope:
animals, birds, fish—earthly dominion, not cosmic dominion.Negative universal expressions (“nothing,” “not one”) always refer to the category under discussion.
5. What “The Beginning” Means in Scripture
The “beginning” in John 1:1 is the same “beginning” as Genesis 1:1—the beginning which consists of all six days of creation (Exodus 20:11; 31:17).
This beginning is:
- after God created the universe
- after the angels already existed (Job 38:4–7)
- includes the creation of mankind and earthly life
Thus, John 1:1–3 refers to the beginning of the world of mankind, not the beginning of all existence.
NT usage confirms this:
- Matthew 19:4; Mark 10:6 — “the beginning” refers to the creation of man and woman
- Matthew 24:21; Mark 13:19 — “the beginning of the world” (kosmos)
- John 1:10 — the world Jesus entered
The New Testament writers consistently use “the beginning” to refer to earthly creation, not the entire created universe.
6. Colossians 1:15–17 Speaks of a Different Creation Category
Colossians 1:15–16 includes:
- visible and invisible powers
- heavenly and earthly dominions
This is a broader category than John 1:3.
John 1:3 speaks of the world of mankind.
Colossians 1:15–16 speaks of all living dominions, both heavenly and earthly.Both are true, but they refer to different scopes of creation.
7. The Order of Creation According to Scripture
Putting the biblical data together:
- Yahweh alone created the material universe, assuming that Isaiah 44:24 actually excludes the existence of anyone else.
- After the universe existed, God created the spirit world.
- The firstborn of all creation (Colossians 1:15) was the prehuman Jesus.
- Through this firstborn Son, God created the rest of the heavenly and earthly dominions (Colossians 1:16–17).
- Later, through the same Son, God brought into being the world of mankind described in Genesis 1 and John 1:1-3,10.
Thus, Jesus is:
- created (as God’s firstborn)
- exalted
- the agent through whom God created various orders of life
But he is not the “uncreated Creator.”
Conclusion
John 1:3 does not teach that Jesus created the universe or that he is uncreated.
It teaches that:
- God created the world of mankind
- and He did so through His firstborn Son, the Word.
The “all” in John 1:3 is defined by the “world” of John 1:10, just as “all creation” in Romans 8:22 is defined by the human world subjected to futility.
The Bible consistently presents:
- Jehovah, Jesus' God, as the Creator
- Jesus as the one through whom God carries out His creative works
This is the simple, consistent testimony of Scripture.
For links to more of our studies related to Jesus and Creation:
For links to some of our studies related to creation:
Creation
**********
No comments:
Post a Comment